North American Kirby box art vs. Japanese Kirby box art. Values dissonance or cultural dissonance? Whatever you want to refer to it as, Kirby Triple Deluxe director Shinya Kumazaki has explained why the Japanese box arts for Kirby games vary so greatly from the North American box arts:
"For the Japanese versions we are, at [Kirby series developer] HAL, involved in everything throughout development, including the package design. The most powerful image of Kirby is that cute image, we think that's the one that appeals to the widest audience," explained Kumazaki in an interview with GameSpot.
"While it does start cute," Kumazaki continues, "we know there is a serious side to Kirby as well, and throughout the gameplay we see more and more of that, and the games themselves have quite a bit of depth. That being said, we recognise that Kirby's cuteness is his biggest draw in [the Japanese] market."
In short, it is believed that the Japanese consumers will find a cute Kirby more attractive whereas American consumers will find a more aggressive Kirby appealing. A TV Tropes article sums up this value dissonance very well:
"Japanese culture in general is very accepting of cuteness pretty much anyplace, and will take it in stride. American culture, on the other hand, often views cuteness as a sign of childish and immiturity, and thus has a strong aversion to it in any media that's not explicitly kid-oriented. "Cutesy" is a loaded term synonymous with "wussy" or "kiddie" to most Americans, who often feel that, if a game or movie is to be taken seriously, then it must have a serious, or at least adult, tone."
However, it is not always the case. Take the box art for Kirby's Epic Yarn. In both American and Japanese markets Kirby is presented as cute and welcoming - it would be contradictory if he wasn't, given the yarn theme. The game sold well in North America, even though the box art did not feature the aggressive Kirby which has been marketed to the West for so long.
Also, take the recent box art of Kirby: Triple Deluxe in Japan, which portrays the aggressive Kirby instead of the cuter one:
Is there a version of Kirby you prefer to see on your box art? Is one more appealing than the other, and does this really impact the franchise's sales? Let us know what you think in the comments section.
Kirby and the Rainbow Curse isn't a traditional Kirby game. It is instead a sequel to 2005's Nintendo DS title, Kirby: Canvas Curse. In that game, players...
Nintendo has announced a full line-up of Virtual Console games that are set to be released on the Wii U in April 2014. For the first time on the Wii U,...
-Little Mac is joining the Super Smash Bros. for Wii U and 3DS cast. The pint-sized hero of the Punch-Out franchise attacks with a flurry of boxing blows....
More news is trickling out of Nintendo's consistently-impressive Nintendo Direct presentation. This morning, two new titles - Kirby Triple Deluxe and...
1 day ago
At their PAX Panel today, Volition (the creators of the Saints Row and Red Faction franchises) announced a new standalone DLC for Saints Row IV, called...
1 day ago
It seems that, as well as working on MewGenics (which will be coming out some time this year), Team Meat have been busy developing a Super Meat Boy spin-off...
14 hours ago
Nintendo’s marketing for its Wii U console has been met with little positivity thus far. One of the biggest impediments to the system establishing its...
1 day ago
2 days ago
GTA Online will soon have had so many updates that it won't be able to fit on a 12GB PS3, Rockstar have warned in a recent support post. The blog post...
4 days ago
Nintendo has been quiet on the Wii U’s newest hit, Mario Kart 8, ever since announcing the Mercedes DLC which is set to release tomorrow. Today, however,...