Xbox 360 Achievements:
| Just a little tipple... | 10 | |
| Drank first rum | ||
| Big Game Hunter | 50 | |
| Killed 2000 monsters | ||
| Bane of the Beasts | 30 | |
| Killed 500 monsters | ||
| Pet Cemetery | 10 | |
| Killed 20 ambient animals | ||
| Deep Sea Fisherman | 10 | |
| Killed 50 sea monsters | ||
| Crab Catcher | 10 | |
| Killed 10 giant crabs | ||
| Beginner | 10 | |
| Killed 10 monsters | ||
| Legendary Hero | 20 | |
| Collected 20 legendary items | ||
| Storyteller | 10 | |
| Collected 10 legendary items | ||
| Treasure Hunter | 10 | |
| Found first treasure in the game | ||
| Made of Money | 50 | |
| Acquired 300,000 gold | ||
| Cash Cow | 30 | |
| Acquired 100,000 gold | ||
| Skinflint | 10 | |
| Acquired 1000 gold | ||
| Protector | 10 | |
| Won duel against Severin | ||
| Digger | 10 | |
| Dug up 50 treasures | ||
| Kleptomaniac | 10 | |
| Picked 100 locks | ||
| Crack Shot | 10 | |
| Hit 10 times in one game in the shooting mini-game | ||
| Drunkard | 10 | |
| Won drinking duel mini-game 10 times | ||
| Birdbrain | 10 | |
| Used parrot 5 times | ||
| Tour Guide | 10 | |
| At least 5 crew members on the ship | ||
| All-Rounder | 30 | |
| Learned each skill once | ||
| Voodoo Wizard | 20 | |
| Learned everything about voodoo | ||
| Rogue | 20 | |
| Learned everything about cunning | ||
| Tough Bastard | 20 | |
| Learned everything about toughness | ||
| Gunslinger | 20 | |
| Learned everything about firearms | ||
| Blademaster | 20 | |
| Learned everything about blades | ||
| Mr Industrious | 50 | |
| Completed 250 quests | ||
| Necromancer | 20 | |
| 'The Split Soul' completed | ||
| Cheese Knife | 20 | |
| 'The Cunning Captain' completed | ||
| Tub Captain | 20 | |
| 'Build a Raft' completed | ||
| Friend of the Gnomes | 20 | |
| 'The Gnome Eater' completed | ||
| Provisions Master | 20 | |
| 'Ship's Equipment' completed | ||
| The Hand of God | 20 | |
| 'The Greedy Captain' completed | ||
| The Right Hand | 20 | |
| 'Chaka Datu's Legacy' completed | ||
| Captain | 30 | |
| 'A New Ship' completed | ||
| Harpooner | 20 | |
| 'The Titan Weapon' completed | ||
| Liberator | 10 | |
| 'Free Hawkins' completed | ||
| Voodoo Pirate | 20 | |
| 'The Ancestors' Blessing' completed | ||
| Knight in Shining Armour | 10 | |
| 'Rescue Patty!' completed | ||
| Secret Achievements | ||
| Monkey Dance | 10 | |
| Used monkey 20 times | ||
| Seafarer | 10 | |
| Travelled by ship 20 times | ||
| The Curse Is Broken! | 50 | |
| 'Kill Mara' completed | ||
| Lord of the Tentacle | 50 | |
| 'Defeat the Kraken' completed | ||
| Ghost Pirate | 20 | |
| 'The Journey to the Underworld' completed | ||
| Artefact Hunter | 20 | |
| 'Steelbeard's Artefact' completed | ||
| Detective | 20 | |
| 'Garcia's Masquerade Uncovered' completed | ||
| Bookworm | 20 | |
| 'Following Garcia's Trail' completed | ||
| Pirate with Muskets | 20 | |
| 'Four Muskets against Crow' completed | ||
| Pirate | 20 | |
| 'Become a Pirate' completed | ||
| He Really Exists! | 20 | |
| 'Find Steelbeard' completed | ||
| DLC: Treasure Isle | ||
| Cost: 800 MSP Achievements: 6 Points: 100 | ||
| Robinson Crusoe | 10 | |
| 'The Marooned Sailor' completed | ||
| Templar | 10 | |
| 'The Air Temple' completed | ||
| Alligator Jack | 20 | |
| Killed all alligators on Treasure Isle | ||
| Long John Silver | 10 | |
| Set course for Treasure Isle for the first time | ||
| Secret Achievements | ||
| Exterminator | 30 | |
| Killed all gargoyles and gave their eggs to Eldric | ||
| Grave Robber | 20 | |
| Opened every deadly chest once | ||
