The game features the following extra characters:
- Elrond (Second Age / Third Age)
- Gil-galad
- Bilbo Baggins (Normal / Old)
- Tom Bombadil
- Rosie
- Ringwraith (Normal / Twilight)
- Gloin
- Moria Orc
- Uruk-hai
- Lurtz (Normal / Newborn)
- Galadriel
- Celeborn
- Gondor Ranger
- Easterling
- Grishnákh
- Radagast the Brown
- King Théoden (Cursed)
- Éowyn (Normal)
- Háma
- Gamling
- Grima Wormtongue
- Haldir
- Lothlórien Elf
- Berserker
- Éomer
- Gondor Soldier
- Saruman the White
- Mordor Orc
- King of the Dead
- Soldier of the Dead
- Rohirrim Soldier
- The Witch-king
- Denethor
- Gothmog
- Citadel Guard
- Corsair
- Haradrim
- Boromir (Captain)
- Blacksmith
