The following is a list of playable wrestlers in the game, including the three released DLC packs, which lists their rating according to the game, as well as their finishing move.
| Name | Rating | Finisher |
| AJ Lee | 77 | Black Widow |
| Aksana | 78 | Divo Drop |
| Alberto Del Rio | 89 | Cross Armbreaker |
| Andre the Giant | 89 | Sitdown Splash; Double Underhook Suplex |
| Antonio Cesaro | 88 | The Neutralizer |
| Batista | 90 | Batista Bomb |
| Big E Langston | 86 | Big Ending |
| Big John Studd | 86 | Reverse Bear Hug; Backbreaker |
| Big Show | 90 | Chokeslam; KO Punch; Colossal Clutch |
| Big Show (Retro) | 90 | Chokeslam; KO Punch; Colossal Clutch |
| Bret Hart | 94 | Sharpshooter |
| Brie Bella | 76 | Bella Buster |
| Brock Lesnar | 91 | F-5; Kimura Lock |
| Brock Lesnar (Retro) | 91 | F-5 |
| Brodus Clay | 88 | Fall of Humanity |
| Bruno Sammartino | 92 | Bear Hug; Backbreaker |
| Chris Jericho | 90 | The Codebreaker; The Walls of Jericho |
| Chris Jericho (Retro) | 89 | The Codebreaker; The Walls of Jericho |
| Christian | 86 | Killswitch |
| CM Punk | 94 | G.T.S. (Go to Sleep); Anaconda Vise |
| Cody Rhodes | 88 | Cross Rhodes |
| Curt Hennig (nWo) | 88 | Perfectplex |
| Damien Sandow | 87 | Terminus |
| Daniel Bryan | 92 | "Yes!" Lock |
| Darren Young | 84 | Gut Check |
| David Otunga | 84 | The Verdict |
| Dean Ambrose | 88 | Headlock Driver |
| Diesel | 89 | Jackknife Powerbomb |
| Dolph Ziggler | 89 | Zig Zag |
| Drew McIntyre | 84 | Future Shock DDT |
| The American Dream Dusty Rhodes | 87 | Bionic Elbow |
| Eddie Guerrero | 92 | Frog Splash; Lasso from El Paso |
| Edge | 91 | Spear |
| Fandango | 85 | Beauty in Motion |
| Goldberg | 92 | Jackhammer; Spear |
| Heath Slater | 82 | Smash Hit |
| Hulk Hogan | 94 | Leg Drop |
| Hollywood Hulk Hogan | 88 | Leg Drop |
| Jack Swagger | 88 | Patriot Lock |
| Jake "The Snake" Roberts | 88 | DDT |
| JBL | 89 | Clothesline From Hell |
| Jinder Mahal | 80 | Camel Clutch |
| John Cena | 95 | Attitude Adjustment; STF |
| John Cena (Retro) | 93 | Attitude Adjustment; STF |
| Justin Gabriel | 83 | 450 Splash |
| Kaitlyn | 78 | Inverted DDT |
| Kane | 91 | Chokeslam |
| Kane (Retro) | 91 | Chokeslam |
| Kevin Nash (nWo) | 89 | Jackknife Powerbomb |
| Kevin Nash (Outsiders) | 89 | Jackknife Powerbomb |
| King Kong Bundy | 86 | Avalanche Splash |
| Kofi Kingston | 88 | Trouble in Paradise |
| Layla | 78 | Bombshell |
| Lita | 79 | Litacanrana |
| Mark Henry | 89 | World's Strongest Slam |
| Mick Foley | 89 | Mandible Claw; Double Arm DDT |
| Mr. McMahon | 81 | Stunner |
| Natalya | 77 | Sharpshooter |
| Nikki Bella | 76 | Bella Buster |
| R-Truth | 87 | Lie Detector |
| Randy Orton | 92 | RKO |
| Macho Man Randy Savage | 93 | Elbow drop off the top rope |
| Macho Man Randy Savage (nWo) | 90 | Elbow drop off the top rope |
| Razor Ramon | 90 | Razor's Edge |
| Rey Mysterio | 90 | 619; West Coast Pop |
| Ric Flair | 90 | Figure-Four Leglock |
| Ric Flair (Retro) | 92 | Figure-Four Leglock |
| Ravishing Rick Rude | 88 | Rude Awakening |
| Ricky Steamboat | 89 | Diving Crossbody |
| Roman Reigns | 88 | Spear |
| Ryback | 90 | Shell Shocked |
| Santino Marella | 84 | The Cobra |
| Scott Hall (nWo) | 90 | Outsider's Edge |
| Scott Hall (Outsiders) | 90 | Outsider's Edge |
| Scott Steiner (nWo) | 89 | Steiner Recliner |
| Seth Rollins | 88 | Blackout |
| Sgt. Slaughter | 87 | Cobra Clutch |
| Shawn Michaels | 95 | Sweet Chin Music |
| Shawn Michaels (Retro) | 93 | Sweet Chin Music |
| Sheamus | 89 | Brogue Kick, Cloverleaf, Irish Curse Backbreaker, White Noise |
| Sin Cara | 87 | Senton Bomb |
| Stephanie McMahon | 74 | Pedigree |
| Stone Cold Steve Austin | 94 | Stone Cold Stunner |
| Summer Rae | 75 | Spinning Heel Kick |
| Syxx (nWo) | 86 | Buzzkiller |
| Ted DiBiase | 87 | Million Dollar Dream |
| Tensai | 84 | Clawhold STO |
| The Giant (nWo) | 89 | Chokeslam |
| The Great Khali | 84 | Punjabi Plunge; Khali Vise Grip |
| The Miz | 89 | Skull-Crushing Finale, Figure-Four Leglock |
| The Rock | 95 | Rock Bottom; People's Elbow |
| The Rock (Retro) | 93 | Rock Bottom; People's Elbow |
| Titus ONeil | 85 | Clash of the Titus |
| Triple H | 93 | Pedigree |
| Triple H (Retro) | 92 | Pedigree |
| Ultimate Warrior | 93 | Running Splash |
| Undertaker | 93 | Chokeslam; Tombstone; Last Ride |
| Undertaker "American Badass" | 93 | Chokeslam; Tombstone; Last Ride |
| Undertaker (Retro) | 94 | Chokeslam; Tombstone; Last Ride |
| Virgil | 82 | Million Dollar Dream |
| Wade Barrett | 87 | Bull Hammer |
| Yokozuna | 90 | Banzai Drop |
| Zack Ryder | 85 | Zack Attack |
