A Hunting Society representative will approach Connor if he has hunted and skinned one animal, unlocking the first tier of challenges and filling in The Hunting Society Membership on the DNA Tracker. The hunting cabins will now appear on the map (as long as the area has been uncovered) and the player can now visit these cabins to accept missions in a linear progression.
The Hunting Society is the only club that gives rewards, in the form of Native American memento's, that can be viewed in an upstairs room of The Homestead.
| Quest | Requirements | Rewards |
|---|---|---|
| Hunting Challenges 1 | Kill 5 deer. | - |
| Kill a wolf. | ||
| Skin 10 animals. | ||
| Trade hunting spoils worth £500. | ||
| Use bait with a snare to capture five animals. | ||
| Kill a bear with the Hidden Blade. | ||
| Hunting Challenges 2 | Stealth kill 5 animals while using Bait. | - |
| Skin 25 animals. | ||
| Kill 10 animals with the Hidden Blade. | ||
| Capture 20 animals with snares. | ||
| Kill 15 animals with the Bow. | ||
| Hunting Challenges 3 | Skin every species of animal. | - |
| Kill 5 animals from horseback. | ||
| Trade hunting spoils worth a total of £2000. | ||
| Complete your hunting map. | ||
| Have collected 50 undamaged pelts. | ||
| The Man-Eater | Head to the marker in Packanack and use Eagle Sense to analyze the clues, enter the cave, pick up the marked corpse and drop it by the marked area to lure the bear out and defeat it. | Bear Memento |
| Feline Feet | Head to the in Black Creek and use Eagle Sense to analyze the clues and find the Bobcat. You will need to kill the Bobcat before it gets away; if you fail, you will need to restart by exit and re-entering the Animus. | Bobcat Memento |
| The Patriarch | Head to the marker in Diamond Basin and use Eagle Vision to find the golden Elk. Use bait to draw it close to some high brush or below a branch to kill it with your hands. | Deer Memento |
| The Pack Leader | Head to the marker in ??? and hide in the trees to safely shoot and kill the three marked wolves to draw out their leader and kill it as well. | Wolf Memento |
| Acute Cat | Head to the marker in Kanien:keh and find the cougar in the mountain pass and kill it (you will need to approach from the village to climb the cliff side). | Cougar Memento |
| The Elk Bachelor | Head to the hunting society marker in Valley Forge and kill the Elk. | Elk Memento |
